This article originally appeared on the excellent Forza Futbol website. Be sure and check out their regular podcast features on iTunes. Link to the original article here.
Special Guest writer and friend of Forza Futbol, Joseph Sexton joins
us to pay tribute to the underappreciated Unai Emery. You can find more
of his fabulous work at STV, the Irish Examiner, among others as well
as talking on various shows and podcasts including WPFI and Forza
Futbol!
When the news broke last week that Valencia would be parting company
with Unai Emery, it came as no great shock. The intolerance of
los che supporters may be legendary by now. But the writing had been on the wall for some time.
On Monday, president Manuel Llorente paid tribute to the Basque
trainer while confirming what we already knew- that former defensive
stalwart Mauricio Pellegrino would be taking his post. Llorente’s words
were kind, and they were also the truth. “We wish to thank Unai for four
year’s great service at the club. His success in leading us into third
spot again this season is something we are all grateful for”.
And is well worth reflecting upon that success. His predecessors- and
Llorente’s- had led the club the brink of financial meltdown. Two
league titles had been secured by Rafael Benítez, following on closely
from two Champions League final appearances under Hector Cúper. It
represented the most successful period in the club’s history.
But with wage costs already reaching unsustainable levels, Benítez
departed under something of a cloud in 2004. Prior to that second title
success, he had clashed repeatedly with the board over the provision and
control of transfer funds in a manner rather reminiscent of his later
travails atLiverpool. But rather than improve, the club’s fiscal
position grew steadily worse.
There were the dud signings, a raft of whom followed in Claudio
Ranieri’s second spell at the club. Not only were they duds on the
pitch. What now appear to be ludicrously generous contractual terms were
sanctioned, making it difficult to move them on elsewhere.
Managers were hired, fired, and compensated. Stability remained
elusive. But what on the face of it looked to be a smart investment in
the club’s future proved to be albatross around its neck.
A new stadium development was sanctioned, but before it was completed
the bottom fell out of the Spanish property market. SuddenlyValencia
were landed with two stadiums; one they couldn’t sell, and another they
couldn’t afford to finish.
They were also stuck with €500m of debt.
To put that debt into perspective in relation to the club’s finances,
they earned as much from domestic television rights last season as West
Ham United did in England.
In England, West Ham had finished bottom of the pile.
It was into this environment that Unai Emery arrived four summers
ago. What he has managed to achieve in that time represents something of
a minor miracle. Year upon year, he’s been forced into selling off his
best players. Yet every season, he’s kept them competitive on the pitch.
The club took a calculated gamble in 2009 in holding on to David
Villa and David Silva in the hope of securing Champions League
qualification and the financial fillip that would come with it.
That gamble was to pay off. Emery’s reward was to have both sold off to Barcelona and Manchester City. But he never complained.
Instead, he set about rebuilding the squad. As older players retired-
or left- younger ones were brought in for lower fees, and more
manageable contracts. On the park, they barely skipped a beat. Unable to
match the behemoths of Real Madrid and Barça, they at least managed to
plant themselves firmly ahead of the rest of the pack.
The fans never really took to Emery, however. A pragmatic,
intelligent, and tactically flexible coach, he was accused of being too
negative; too defensive. These criticisms seemed harsh. But then these
are the same fans who booed both Benítez and Cúper before him.
Valencia could get down and dirty, as they did earlier this season in
dumping Stoke City out of the Europa League. But they also remained
capable of playing dazzling technical football. The curious aspect of
Emery’s downfall is that his perceived negative streak never really
sufficed to help them see out big games, while the more proactive
aspects of his approach went unheralded.
They never managed to defeat Barcelona, despite coming agonisingly
close on occasion. They never could live with Madrid. They never could
get close to them in the league rankings either. Despite their final
rankings under Emery, they never finished within 20 points of the pair.
At times, Emery was arguably guilty of over-thinking things. Rarely
selecting the same personal or system in consecutive games, he preferred
to cut his cloth to measure on a match by match basis. A man supremely
confident in his own tactical nous, his chopping and changing became
legendary. Sadly for him, so too did his side’s propensity for tossing
away leads. In his four year tenure,Valencia have managed to surrender
winning positions on more than 45 occasions.
That statistic at least allows us to see the fans’ ire in a more
generous light. They were consistent, but at times also infuriating.
That will go down as the greatest paradox of his reign. Good enough to
set about what they were expected of, but not in a manner satisfactory
to the Mestalla crowd.
They secured third spot again last weekend, but came worryingly close
to throwing away what had been a commanding position there. They went
out of the Europa League semi-final against Atlético Madrid with a
whimper, losing 1-0 in their home leg have scraped a scarcely merited
4-2 defeat at the Vicente Calderon. And that is what ultimately sealed
his fate. He departs having failed to secure any silverware.
At least he will be among old friends. Valery Karpin and Dmitry
Popov- both former team-mates- are on the administrative staff at
Spartak Moscow. Karpin indeed, is stepping aside from the manager’s seat
following a turbulent period in the club’s history.
The east represents something of a never-never land for Western
European coaches. Juande Ramos’ already dipping stock remains
irreparably damaged following his disastrous tenure across town at CSKA
though somehow he managed to rebound at Dnipro in the Ukraine. Luciano
Spalletti has overseen a decisive shift in power to former capital at
Zenit of Saint Petersburg. It is the Italian’s example Emery will seek
to emulate. But to do so, he’ll have to unseat the former AS Roma boss
as Russia’s top dog.
Meanwhile, what will happen next at Valencia is anyone’s guess. We
have no way of judging how Mauricio Pellegrino will fare as boss. His
experience to date has come solely in a supporting role, as first team
coach and later assistant to Rafa Benítez at Liverpool & Inter. Top
scorer, Roberto Soldado, spoke to French television on Monday about the
possibility of joining Paris Saint-Germain. His international colleague
Jordi Alba is poised to move the Camp Nou as Eric Abidal’s successor.
Once again, the club will have to rebuild, and so with cut-price
replacements.
Having got what they so evidently wanted, one now wonders if the
supporters will be left learning that sometimes it is prudent to be
careful what you wish for.